Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Local Taste of Italy Since 1974
La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria was founded in December 1974 by Nunzio Cusumano, a Sicilian immigrant who brought his passion for authentic Italian cuisine to Long Island. Over five decades, we have maintained the integrity of our original recipes while evolving into a beloved community landmark that combines tradition with innovation. Our team includes seasoned professionals with decades of collective experience in Italian hospitality, including co-owner Chris, who joined in 2015 after rising from busboy to management. We specialize in homemade Italian dishes crafted daily, from our signature tomato sauce to award-winning pizzas, and offer attentive dine-in, take-out, and catering services.Our catering division serves corporate events, weddings, and family celebrations with the same dedication to quality that earned us recognition in the Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022. With staff members boasting over 20 years of tenure, we pride ourselves on delivering a warm, family-oriented experience that honors our roots while embracing modern culinary standards.
Services
Dine-In
Take-Out
Catering
Pizza Delivery
Event Hosting
Gluten-Free Options
Wine Service
Private Parties
Lunch Specials
Family Meals
Details
- Year established: 1974
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1974 with generations of culinary expertise
- Homemade dishes using time-honored Sicilian recipes
- Award-winning pizza recognized by Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022
- Experienced catering team serving Long Island events since 1974
- Dedicated staff with over 20 years of average tenure
Services
Catering Services
Elevate your event with La Scala's premier catering services featuring authentic Italian cuisine. Our experienced team delivers made-from-scratch dishes for weddings, corporate events, and family celebrations. We handle logistics from menu planning to on-site service, ensuring memorable culinary experiences with options for 10 to 200+ guests.
Award-Winning Pizza
Savor our handcrafted pizzas made with house-made dough and signature tomato sauce. Available in Neapolitan, Sicilian, and specialty styles with gluten-free options. Recognized as a Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022 quarter-finalist, our menu includes classic Margherita and innovative creations like Buffalo Chicken and Baked Ziti pizzas.
Dine-In Experience
Enjoy our warm, family-style dining room serving lunch and dinner daily. Menu features include antipasti, house-made pastas, seafood, veal, and chicken dishes. The lunch menu offers $7$14 specials while dinner showcases premium entres from $19$31, with attentive service from our seasoned staff.
Take-Out & Delivery
Order authentic Italian meals for pickup or delivery through DoorDash. Our menu includes pizzas, pastas, heroes, and family-style platters. Gluten-free and specialty options available. Cash discounts apply for direct orders, with catering available for larger groups.
Private Events
Host special occasions in our fully-equipped dining room accommodating 60+ guests. Packages include full-service catering, customized menus, and event coordination. Available for weddings, birthdays, and corporate functions with pricing starting at $39 per person for three-course meals.
People
Nunzio Cusumano
Founder
Founded La Scala Restaurant & Pizzeria in 1974 at age 21, bringing Sicilian culinary traditions to Long Island. Expanded to multiple Italian restaurants while maintaining ownership until passing leadership to the next generation.
Chris
Co-Owner/Manager
Started at La Scala in 2003, rising from busboy to management before becoming co-owner in 2015. Oversees daily operations while maintaining the restaurant's family-oriented values and culinary standards.
Questions
Does La Scala offer catering services for large events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for weddings, corporate events, and private parties with menus serving 10–200+ guests.
Are there gluten-free options available?
Yes, we offer gluten-free cauliflower crust pizza and pasta alternatives for most menu items.
What awards has La Scala won?
Recognized as a Newsday Pizza Smackdown 2022 quarter-finalist for our signature pizza creations.
Do you deliver outside Commack?
Delivery available through DoorDash within Long Island; catering services cover extended areas.
Can I host a private party at La Scala?
Yes, our dining room accommodates events for 60+ guests with customized catering packages starting at $39/person.