Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Premium Meats Seafood & Catering Services Stewart Manor NY
Pellegrini's Prime Meats, Fish & Catering has been a family-owned institution in Stewart Manor, NY since 1959. Our commitment to quality begins with sourcing premium cuts of meat and fresh seafood, free from antibiotics and growth hormones. With decades of experience, owners Ron and Mike Spieler have cultivated a reputation for exceptional customer service and attention to detail that distinguishes us from other butcheries. Our full-service catering division provides customized solutions for events of all sizes, combining traditional butchery techniques with modern culinary innovation. We maintain the charm of an old-fashioned meat shop while offering contemporary conveniences like online ordering and gift card programs.Our menu features USDA Prime selections, specialty seafood platters, and extensive catering options with professional wait staff. Through five generations of operation, we've preserved our core values of quality, service, and community engagement. Our team of expert chefs and catering professionals ensures every event receives meticulous attention from planning to execution. We serve both individual customers and event planners in Stewart Manor, Garden City, and surrounding areas. Our dedication to freshness and customer satisfaction has earned us the trust of local clients for over six decades.
Services
Premium Meats
Fresh Seafood
Full-Service Catering
BBQ Catering
Holiday Catering
Gift Cards
Online Ordering
Custom Platters
Event Wait Staff
Meat Delivery
Details
- Year established: 1959
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1959 with generational meat-cutting expertise
- USDA Prime certified meat selections available daily
- Full-service catering with professional staff and equipment
- All meats and seafood guaranteed antibiotic and hormone-free
- Customized solutions for events from intimate dinners to large parties
What people say
Exceptional meat quality
Fresh seafood selection
Professional catering staff
Reliable event service
Great family tradition
Services
Full-Service Catering
Customized catering solutions for events of all sizes featuring premium meats and seafood. Our professional team handles everything from menu planning to on-site service with wait staff and bartenders. Available for corporate events, weddings, and private parties in Stewart Manor and surrounding areas.
Premium Meat Sales
Daily selection of USDA Prime cuts including filet mignon, strip steak, and specialty cuts. We offer all-natural beef, pork, lamb, and poultry products free from antibiotics and growth hormones. Custom cuts available upon request.
Fresh Seafood
Daily fresh-caught seafood selection featuring shrimp, lobster, salmon, and shellfish. Our seafood department offers both raw and prepared options with on-site preparation available for catering events.
Holiday Catering
Specialized holiday catering packages for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year's celebrations. Includes complete meal solutions with meats, sides, and desserts serving 10-18 people with advance ordering available.
BBQ Services
On-site BBQ catering with professional grilling equipment and staff. Menu includes gourmet burgers, kebabs, and seafood options with customizable packages starting at $24.95 per person.
People
Ron Spieler
Co-Owner
Co-owner with over 30 years of experience in the meat industry, maintaining quality standards since 1959.
Mike Spieler
Co-Owner
Family member continuing the tradition of excellence in meat selection and customer service since establishment.
Liz
Catering Manager
Professional catering manager coordinating event logistics and menu customization for private and corporate functions.
Questions
Do you offer catering services for large events?
Yes, we provide full-service catering for events of all sizes with professional staff and equipment.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Stewart Manor, Garden City, and surrounding Nassau County areas for both retail and catering services.
Are your meats antibiotic-free?
Yes, all our meats and seafood are guaranteed free from antibiotics and growth hormones.
Do you offer gift cards?
Yes, we offer gift cards in any denomination available for purchase in-store, by phone, or online.
